The Madness of Doctor McCoy

Hank McCoy was one of the original X-Men, and he was also the first X-Man to graduate. He’s had years of experience as a member of the Avengers, and has become the X-Men’s most accomplished scientist. Unfortunately, I happen to be of the view that he’s also going round the bend.

Beast mutates again
This may have been where it all began…

That Beast is a genius is beyond any doubt.  His actual specialism is genetics, although – in true comic-book fashion – he seems able to make the leap to almost anything.  During the 1990s, he was briefly replaced by his Age of Apocalypse counterpart, who was astounded that the X-Men depended on Hank for everything from curing the Legacy Virus to maintaining the X-Mansion’s Shi’ar technology!

But Beast has always had a tendency to jump in the deep end, to want to try things out rather than ensure they’re safe first.  After all, we’re talking about the guy who injected himself with a serum and turned himself blue and furry.  Sorry, Hank, but that one really can’t go down as a success story.

Beast's decision
The story of Beast’s mutation is told in Amazing Adventures 11-17.

No doubt that experimental nature is why he can make technology sing and dance – he just gives it a shot, and sees what happens.  His most recent masterpiece is the Jean Grey School, filled with advanced technology that even he seems barely in control of.

Beast JGS

Here’s the catch, though.  You have an incredibly smart guy, with a tendency to jump in the deep end.

And you have a guy who makes very dangerous choices when under pressure.

In the 1990s, the mutant race seemed to be on the brink of extinction (again).  The madman named Stryfe had released a devastating illness that targeted only mutants, the Legacy Virus.  And the Beast was the man on the ground, the scientist struggling to deal with the threat around him.  In the haunting X-Men #27, Hank visited an old enemy, fellow geneticist Infectia.  She was dying of the Legacy Virus, and he made a startling choice; he took her out of containment.  I’m yet to uncover the references for this, but it’s commonly argued that Infectia’s out-of-control powers at the time of her death were what caused the release of a strain of the Legacy Virus that affected humans too.

Fearing the Legacy Virus was beyond him, Beast chose to allow Sinister to take the mentally-disturbed Threnody under his wing, believing Sinister’s lack of morals would give him a better chance to cure the disease.  Hardly a morally uplifting choice of Hank’s.

Threnody
Poor Threnody back then was hardly the most stable of individuals…

This same tendency emerged in the 2000s, with the mutant race (again) brought to the edge of extinction – this time by the words of the Scarlet Witch.  Hank was willing to compromise with his dark doppelganger in order to reverse the Decimation, but was ultimately unsuccessful.

During the same period, in the Secret Invasion: X-Men miniseries, Hank was willing to release a strain of the Legacy Virus against the Skrulls.  Had any Skrull gotten back to the main armada, Hank would have just committed genocide.  But step aside from that fact for a second; consider that Hank McCoy has kept a sample of the Legacy Virus.  Yes, he mutated his sample; but at any time, no matter where he stored it, he couldn’t have guaranteed it wouldn’t have become airborne (particularly given how often X-Men bases get destroyed).

Beast has Legacy
At least he doesn’t exactly seem overjoyed!

More recently, it’s gotten even more disturbing.  In the aftermath of AvX, Hank began making seriously questionable choices.  Fearing a mutant civil war (as though mutants had ever been a united race), Hank stepped back in time and summoned the original X-Men.  In ANXM #25, The Watcher has stripped away all Hank’s reasons, and essentially exposed a long-repressed love for Jean Grey that led Hank to just desperately hope he could give her a better life by bringing her into the present.  Unfortunately, it looks extremely likely that in doing so, Hank broke the timeline.

No Mutant civil war
Not exactly an honest pitch, either.

Now, I think things are building to a head.  In Battle of the Atom, we have Hank meet a future version of himself who is both ugly and insane.  Worse still, in Wolverine and the X-Men #42, a future Wolverine reflects that Hank must have been beginning to go crazy even back when he designed the Jean Grey School.

Future Beast
One day, perhaps, Hank will stop mutating!

And then we have The Watcher’s words: “You disgust me, Hank McCoy,” The Watcher pronounced as a judgment, and the weight of guilt upon Hank’s shoulders only increased.  Under the weight of this guilt, what will Hank choose to do?  He has ideas, I’m sure, and they may not be pleasant ones.

Watcher disgusted
Talk about putting a man in his place–!

Let me add one final worrying thought to the mix, to help you realise the extent of the problem the world faces if Hank McCoy is truly going insane.  Beast is a member of a covert group of heroes known as the Illuminati, who have taken it upon themselves to protect the Earth at all costs – even destroying whole worlds in order to keep Earth safe (see New Avengers).  Along with a handful of other heroes, he wields more covert influence than any of the other X-Men.

Worlds End
Yes, to save the Earth, the Illuminati – including Hank – have destroyed worlds.

To give you an idea of the scale of it all, picture these words from Black Swan in New Avengers #5 – a being who traverses the universes.

Black Swan and Beast

Can the X-Men afford their best and brightest to go insane?  Can the Marvel Universe?

And take a look at this amazing sketch, designed by Anthony Henderson!

Beast sketch

 

4 Comments Add yours

  1. comicnewbies says:

    If I remember correctly, it was Cyclops who forced Beast to use the modified Legacy Virus on the Skrulls. But beyond that, I agree Beast is a douche riding a high horse.

    Like

    1. True, hence the image I posted – and yet, Beast takes part of it on himself. I do think the thing that’s scariest is the idea that Beast has kept a *sample* of the Legacy Virus!

      Like

  2. Reblogged this on _Justpressplay and commented:
    Great character piece- that highlights why ‘Beast’ isn’t the heart of the X-men, but a man who has always strived to cure himself and better himself at the expense of others- and more recently time and the universe itself

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s