Review: All-New X-Men Annual 2014

The time-sweeping adventures of Tempus come to an end in ‘All-New X-Men Annual’.  And it’s pulled off with tremendous skill, leaving me very, very impressed with Brian Bendis’ writing!

I say again that Bendis has made an extremely gutsy choice in making Eva Bell the star of the annuals.  Whereas usually you get an annual featuring a band of mutants, in these annuals you’ve had just the one major character, with time and space rewriting themselves around her.

This issue is an extremely important one, as well, justifying its being part of ‘All-New X-Men’.  The parallels between Tempus in 2099 – experiencing and living in a future that ceases to exist the moment she return – and the All-New X-Men are obvious.  Is it possible that, the moment he brought the All-New X-Men into the present day, Hank McCoy rewrote history?  Is it possible that the timeline as we know it hangs together by a thread, purely based on the fact that the All-New X-Men are still here?

Time is not Linear
Finally, there are RULES to time-travel!

Bendis gives us two unusual ‘voices’ through which we learn these lessons: Morgana Le Fey, introduced in a brilliant but oh-so-logical twist, and a future Sorcerer Supreme.  But undeniably, the focus is on Tempus and on the lessons that she must learn.  Bendis is smart in his timings, giving a gentle nod towards an arc that is fulfilled in the same week’s ‘Uncanny X-Men #29’, and making the whole thing look like a masterclass in writing comics.

The quality of the art remains breathtakingly high, although it’s hard to wince at one scene that ignores ‘Marvel Time’ and essentially tears the shifting timeline of Marvel Comics to shreds.  Particularly when the discomfort of those splash pages – which are otherwise superb – could have been mitigated by the simple recourse of not putting years on the images we see.

Marvel Time is Broken
See what I mean?

The story of Eva Bell has come to a logical conclusion here, boding ill for the future, while also completing a tale of painful human tragedy.  When the Sorcerer Supreme discusses it, his understatement just makes it all the more horrible.  Once again, Brian Bendis has put together an issue that I’ve really enjoyed, and I consider myself thoroughly impressed.

My score: 9/10 (due to the logic gap with ‘Marvel Time’)

3 Comments Add yours

  1. Iñigo PM says:

    Eva looked like an interesting character since her introduction in All-New #1. But when the O5 came back and became the stars of the book, she, along all the new characters, had to take a back seat and stayed underdeveloped. It’s good to see them taking an active role in the book again. However, this is an example of the problem that causes having so many characters and creating even more just to leave a mark. Btw, merry x-mas


    1. I agree. To me, what they ought to do is have each book with a unique cast, some of whom are newer characters!

      Merry Christmas! 😀


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s